Stephen Walt is a pretty decent foreign policy wonk, so I was excited to check out his Top 10 Foreign Policy Movies list. And, of course, I realized that 1) I need to pick his apart and 2) I could make a way better list.
You can read Stephen’s selection explanations here. I haven’t seen all of his choices (but they are in my Netflix queue!), and he disqualified spy capers, war epics and documentaries…but since he broke his own rules, I am breaking them too.
10. Stephen Picked: Meeting Venus
I Picked: The Manchurian Candidate
I haven’t seen Meeting Venus, but I have seen BOTH versions of the Manchurian Candidate (I prefer the older one because Angela Lansbury’s acting is so good that I have nightmares about her character). This is the archetypal Cold War brainwashing movie, almost as good as those DoD-produced films narrated by Jack Webb. Just thinking about this flick makes me want to watch it again. Plus, Frank Sinatra!
9. Stephen Picked: Independence Day
I Picked: Team America: World Police

8. Stephen Picked: Syriana
I Picked: Charlie Wilson’s War
Um, Stephen said his CIA friends said Charlie Wilson’s War is mostly bunk. Aside from how that sounds sort of eighth-grade gossip-y, CWW upset a lot of important people with big egos, so of course they’re gonna say it’s bunk. That shouldn’t disqualify it from making the cut—or worse—allow the choosing of a crapstorm like Syriana instead. Syriana was impossible to follow and utterly stupid. If See No Evil had received the same film treatment as CWW, I wouldn’t be sitting here complaining. Maybe I would, but it would be about something else of great importance.
7. Stephen Picked: Judgment at Nuremberg
I Picked: The Lives of Others
Actually, I bet Judgment at Nuremberg is good, I just haven’t seen it. I have seen The Lives of Others, which is an incredible movie, so that’s why it’s on here (duh). Man, I’m kind of losing steam and we’re only at #7.
6. Stephen Picked: Wag the Dog
I Picked: Clear and Present Danger
“I’m sorry, Mr. President. I don’t dance.”
If you are looking for a foreign policy scandal-ish movie, look no further. Clear and Present Danger is phenomenal—probably the best in the Jack Ryan series. Drugs! Corruption! A thinly-veiled version of Iran-Contra!
5. Stephen Picked: Fail Safe
I Picked: The Battle of Algiers
How is Battle of Algiers not on his list? Amateur hour. You can’t have a serious Cold War “will we blow up the world” drama AND a comedy version on the same list. There are rules! So I’m replacing his choice with this movie…advance warning, though it’s amazing, it’s also v. difficult to watch. But it’s good in a way because you can see how things in Algeria have gotten so much bet—oh wait.
4. Stephen Picked: Gandhi/A Passage to India
I Picked: Jarhead/Three Kings
Oh, sorry, you can’t choose a spy caper but you can add an India twofer? What the hell? So I am gonna do the same with the Middle East. I prefer Three Kings (Marky Mark!) to Jarhead, but they’re both worth watching.
3. Stephen Picked: The Great Dictator
I Picked: Dirty Dancing: Havana Nights
This is for Alyson, Becca and Cella. AND CUUUUUUBBBBBAAAAAAA!
2. Stephen Picked: Dr. Strangelove
I Picked: Dr. Strangelove
A meeting of the minds. Or perhaps we just watched my #10 selection?
1. Stephen Picked: Casablanca
I Picked: Lawrence of Arabia
This is the biggest crime on his entire list. I love Casablanca as much as the next person, but give me a damn break. This does not belong on a foreign policy film list, ESPECIALLY one that doesn’t include Lawrence of Arabia, which is only THE MOST IMPORTANT FOREIGN POLICY MOVIE OF ALL TIME. No joke, when I scrolled down to the bottom of Stephen’s list and saw that it was missing…I actually got angry. I felt my blood pressure rise. How could Stephen do this to me, to us, to fopo nerds and movie nerds and regular nerds everywhere?
I feel that I’ve righted this wrong. What up now, Stephen. What up now.